The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy at All: Character & Story Guide - Music

The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy at All: Character & Story Guide

A fan guide to Sumiko Arai's yuri manga: Aya and Mitsuki, the record-store premise, volumes, music themes, awards, and the 2027 anime.

2026-10-10
The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy at All Wiki Team
Quick Guide
  • The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy at All is a yuri romance manga by Sumiko Arai
  • The story follows Aya Oosawa and Mitsuki Koga, connected through rock music and a record store
  • It won the Web Manga category at the 2023 Next Manga Awards
  • Over 2.25 million copies sold and 2M+ social followers as of 2026
  • An anime adaptation is scheduled to premiere on Crunchyroll in 2027

Story Overview: A Misunderstanding Built on Music

The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy at All (Japanese: Kini Otenai Hito ga Otoko Janakatta, 気になってる人が男じゃなかった) turns a simple case of mistaken identity into one of the most talked-about yuri romances of the decade. Aya Oosawa, a fashionable and outgoing high-school girl, becomes fascinated by a stylish, cool employee at a local record store. What she does not realize is that the person behind the counter is Mitsuki Koga — her quiet female classmate, whose androgynous shop persona sparked the misunderstanding that gives the series its title.

The series blends yuri romance, school life, slice-of-life comedy, and a deep love of rock and alternative music culture. Music is not just decoration: records, headphones, and album artwork form the shared language through which Aya and Mitsuki slowly come to understand each other.

Video Highlights:

  • Official anime teaser released by Crunchyroll
  • Confirms the 2027 streaming premiere window
  • First animated look at Aya and Mitsuki

According to the official anime site, the series has surpassed 2.25 million copies in global circulation and over 2 million social media followers — remarkable numbers for a web-origin yuri manga.

ElementDetails
AuthorSumiko Arai (新井すみこ)
Japanese title気になってる人が男じゃなかった
Publisher (Japan)KADOKAWA
English publisherYen Press
GenreYuri, school romance, slice-of-life, music
Anime premiere2027 (Crunchyroll)
Spoiler-Free Promise

This guide keeps major plot turns unmarked and spoiler-light, so first-time readers can explore characters, themes, and releases safely.

Main Characters: Aya and Mitsuki

The romance works because the two leads occupy opposite ends of the social spectrum. Aya is expressive, fashion-forward, and quick to fixate on someone who catches her eye. Mitsuki is reserved, speaks more fluently through music than conversation, and carries a second identity as the effortlessly cool record-store employee.

Aya Oosawa

  • Outgoing and fashionable gyaru-inspired style
  • Falls for the mysterious shop clerk
  • Drawn into alternative and rock music through her crush

Mitsuki Koga

  • Quiet classmate with deep music knowledge
  • Androgynous style fuels Aya's misunderstanding
  • More comfortable expressing herself through records than words

Aya and Mitsuki

  • Contrasting personalities with shared musical ground
  • Music acts as their bridge between two different worlds
  • Slow-building romantic tension drives the series
CharacterSchool IdentityMusic ConnectionKey Trait
Aya OosawaFashionable, sociable studentNewcomer drawn to rock via the record storeEnthusiastic, direct
Mitsuki KogaQuiet classmate of AyaExpert-level knowledge, works at the shopReserved, cool
The pairingClassmatesShared listening habitsEmotional contrast
Why the Dynamic Works

The identity misunderstanding never reduces either girl to a stereotype. Instead, it creates space for both characters to discover who the other person really is, one small moment at a time.

Reading Order and Where to Buy

The English edition from Yen Press is best read in numbered-volume order. Start with Volume 1 to meet Aya, Mitsuki, the record-store setting, and the misunderstanding that launches the story, then continue with Volume 2.

VolumeReading OrderMain ContentEdition
Vol. 1FirstAya, Mitsuki, the record store, the identity misunderstandingEnglish (Yen Press)
Vol. 2SecondDeepening relationship, school life, new emotional beatsEnglish (Yen Press)
Series pageOngoingOfficial listing for future volumesPublisher page

Authorized digital storefronts include BOOK☆WALKER for digital volumes. Availability and formats vary by storefront, so confirm the specific volume before purchasing. Japanese editions are available through KADOKAWA.

Support Official Releases

Avoid unofficial scan sites. The series' web-manga origins make piracy common — buying official volumes directly supports Sumiko Arai and future English releases.

Themes, Music, and Recognition

Music defines the series' identity. The record store is not a backdrop but the story's central meeting point, where music knowledge, visual presentation, and curiosity bring the two girls together.

Rock as Atmosphere

  • Album covers, records, and headphones shape the visual mood
  • Adds texture to quiet romantic scenes
  • Separates the series from standard school romance

Identity and Self-Expression

  • Public personas versus private selves
  • First impressions and how they break down
  • Music taste as a window into Mitsuki's inner life
RecognitionDetails
2023 Next Manga AwardsWinner, Web Manga category
Global circulation2.25M+ copies
Social reach2M+ followers
Author interviewSumiko Arai discusses music and creative background with uDiscover Music

The series' crossover appeal spans yuri readers, school-romance fans, and music-culture enthusiasts — a combination recognized when it took the top Web Manga prize at the 2023 Next Manga Awards.

Newcomer-Friendly Entry Point

If you are new to yuri, this series is frequently recommended as a starting point thanks to its accessible premise, stylish art, and low barrier to entry.

Beginner Reading Path

1

Understand the Premise

Aya falls for a cool record-store clerk who turns out to be her female classmate Mitsuki. This misunderstanding powers the early tension.

2

Follow the Emotional Core

Focus on how Aya and Mitsuki grow closer through curiosity, awkward conversations, and shared listening habits.

3

Savor the Small Moments

School corridors, part-time work, fashion, and behavioral shifts matter as much as big romantic developments.

4

Track the Music Layers

Pay attention to records and references — they reveal character and signal emotional beats.

5

Watch for the Anime

With the Crunchyroll adaptation arriving in 2027, finishing early volumes now puts you ahead of the anime audience.

First-Time Reader Checklist:

  • Read Volume 1 in full
  • Notice the identity misunderstanding setup
  • Track recurring music references
  • Follow the official anime site for 2027 updates
  • Add Volume 2 to your reading list

FAQ

Q: Is The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy at All a yuri manga?

Yes. The series is a yuri (girls' love) romance centered on the developing relationship between Aya Oosawa and Mitsuki Koga, blended with school-life comedy and music-culture elements.

Q: When does the anime premiere?

The official anime adaptation is scheduled to premiere in 2027 and will stream on Crunchyroll, according to the official teaser and anime website.

Q: How many English volumes are available?

Yen Press has published the series in English starting with Volume 1, followed by Volume 2. Check the official Yen Press series page for the latest volume releases.

Q: Is the series worth reading if I am new to yuri?

Frequently, yes. Its accessible mistaken-identity premise, stylish art, award recognition, and music-centered atmosphere make it a common recommendation for readers entering the genre.